2 Fat Guys
2019, 2018, 2016, 2013
8th & Union Kitchen
2016, 2015
BBC Tavern and Grill
2014, 2013, 2012
Brew Haha!
2017
Brick Works Brewing & Eats
2017
Buckley's Tavern
2014, 2013
(plus Grilled Cheese Battle 2018)
Cantwell's Tavern
2015, 2013
Chelsea Tavern
NINE YEAR COMPETITOR
2012-2022
WINNER:
2016 PEOPLE'S CHOICE,
2022+2018+2015 CRITICS CHOICE
Crave Eatery
2015
Cromwell's American Tavern & Taqueria
2022
Deer Park Tavern
2015, 2014
WINNER: 2014 CRITICS CHOICE
Delaware Provision Company
2016
Delaware Park Racetrack & Casino
At the Rail Wine Bar & Grill
2017, 2016, 2015
Drip Cafe (and previously
The Brunch Box)
2018, 2016, 2015, 2014
Farmer & the Cow
2022, 2019, 2018
WINNER: 2022 ALTERNATIVE BURGER
Firebirds Wood Fired Grill
2016
Grain Craft Bar & Kitchen
2019
The Green Stinger, 2019
Hamilton's on Main
2022
WINNER: 2022 PEOPLE'S CHOICE
Harry's Savoy Grill
2012
Home Grown Café
2019, 2018, 2017, 2015, 2013
WINNER: 2018+2015 ALTERNATIVE BURGER
(and Grilled Cheese Battle 2018. 2019)
Jake's Wayback Burgers
2013
James Street Tavern
2012
Kelly's Logan House
2015
Kid Shelleen's
2013, 2012
La Fia Bistro
2014
Lefty's Alley & Eats
2019, 2018
Makers Alley
2022
Market Kitchen & Bar
2018
McGlynn's Pub & Restaurant
2017, 2016
The Meat House, Chadds Ford
2017, 2016, 2015, 2014
Nordstrom Grill
2016
WINNER: 2016 CRITICS CHOICE
Piccolina Toscana
2016, 2012
Pizza by Elizabeths
2015, 2014, 2013, 2012
The Queen, 2019
Redfire Grill & Steakhouse
NINE YEAR COMPETITOR
2012-2022
WINNER:
2017+2013 CRITICS CHOICE, 2018+2014 PEOPLES CHOICE
Sherm's Catering
2018
Skipjack
2014
Sullivan's Steakhouse
2012
Ted's Montana Grill
2019, 2018
Tonic Bar and Grille
2018, 2017, 2016
Ulysses Gastropub
SEVEN YEAR COMPETITOR
2012-2018
WINNER: 2014 ALTERNATIVE
Uncle John's BBQ
2019, 2022
University & Whist Club
2018
Zach's Grill
2022
Eppy's BBQ
2012
Ernest & Scott Taproom
2012-2017, 2019
Grub Burger Bar
2017
WINNER: 2017 ALTERNATIVE BURGER
I Don't Give a Fork, 2015
Kildare's Irish Pub
2014, 2013, 2012
WINNER: 2012 CRITICS CHOICE
Maiale Deli & Salumeria
2018, 2017, 2016, 2015
WINNER: 2019x2 CRITICS AND ALTERNATIVE! 2017+2015 PEOPLES CHOICE
Matilda's, 2015, 2012
Metro Pub & Grill
2018, 2017
WINNER: 2019 PEOPLE'S CHOICE
Nage Restaurant, 2014, 2013
Orillas Tapas Bar, 2012
Rose & Crown, 2014
Tutto Fresco, 2014
UDairy Creamery Market
2019
Union City Grille
2013, 2012
WINNER: 2013 PEOPLES CHOICE, 2012 PEOPLES CHOICE
World Cafe Live at the Queen
2014, 2013
Historical winners:
Critics Choice Burger: 2022+2018+2015-Chelsea Tavern, 2019-Maiale Deli & Salumeria, 2017+2013-Redfire Grill & Steakhouse, 2016-Nordstrom Grill, 2014-Deer Park Tavern, 2012-Kildare's
People’s Choice Burger: 2022-Hamilton's on Main, 2019-Metro Pub & Grill, 2018+2014-Redfire Grill & Steakhouse, 2017+2015-Maiale Deli & Salumeria, 2016-Chelsea Tavern, 2013+2012-Union City Grille
Best Alternative Burger: 2022-Farmer & the Cow, 2019-Maiale Deli & Salumeria, 2018+2015-Home Grown Cafe, 2017-Grub Burger Bar, 2014-Ulysses Gastropub
List as of 2018
Total restaurants by year:
2022 - 9
2019 - 15
2018 - 15
2017 - 16
2016 - 16
2015 - 17
2014 - 18
2013 - 16
2012 - 18
List as of 2022